What Is the Difference Between a Living Will and a Healthcare Proxy?
By CRYSTAL BAI •
The short answer: A living will documents your specific medical treatment wishes in writing. A healthcare proxy (durable power of attorney for health care) designates a trusted person to make medical decisions when you cannot. They serve different but complementary functions — and most people need both for comprehensive end-of-life planning.
Two Documents, Two Different Jobs
Advance care planning involves two distinct types of documents that work together. Understanding the difference is essential for effective end-of-life planning.
What Is a Living Will?
A living will (also called a healthcare directive or directive to physicians) is a written document that specifies your wishes for medical treatment if you become unable to communicate and are facing a terminal illness, permanent unconsciousness, or end-stage condition. It is your voice when you cannot speak for yourself.
A living will typically addresses:
- Whether you want cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) if your heart stops
- Whether you want mechanical ventilation to breathe for you
- Whether you want artificial nutrition and hydration (feeding tube)
- Whether you want dialysis to perform kidney function
- Your preferences around pain management and comfort care
- Organ and tissue donation wishes
What Is a Healthcare Proxy (Durable Power of Attorney for Health Care)?
A healthcare proxy — also called a durable power of attorney for health care, healthcare agent, or medical power of attorney depending on the state — is a legal document that designates a specific person to make medical decisions on your behalf when you cannot make them yourself.
Your healthcare proxy can:
- Interpret your stated wishes in situations your living will did not anticipate
- Communicate with medical teams and advocate for your values
- Make real-time decisions as your condition evolves
- Consent to or refuse treatments
The healthcare proxy is the person; the healthcare power of attorney is the document that gives them legal authority.
How They Work Together
A living will without a proxy leaves specific instructions but no decision-maker for unexpected situations. A proxy without a living will leaves a trusted person without documented guidance from you. Together, they ensure that your values and wishes are both documented and represented:
- The living will speaks to what you want in foreseeable scenarios
- The proxy interprets and applies your values in all other scenarios
Choosing Your Healthcare Proxy
Your healthcare proxy should be:
- Someone you trust deeply to honor your values, not their own
- Someone who can handle stress and conflict with medical teams or family members
- Someone who is willing and able to be present and make difficult decisions
- Someone who will follow your wishes even when it is hard — including decisions to withdraw treatment
Your healthcare proxy does not have to be a family member. Many people choose a close friend who better understands their values. Discuss your wishes explicitly with whoever you choose.
State-Specific Requirements
Both documents are governed by state law. Most states require either two witnesses or notarization (or both). Witnesses generally cannot be your healthcare proxy, a family member, or your physician. A death doula or end-of-life planner can help you complete the correct forms for your state. Forms are available free through state health departments and organizations like Five Wishes and CaringInfo.
POLST Is Not the Same as an Advance Directive
A POLST (Physician Orders for Life-Sustaining Treatment) — called MOST, POST, or MOLST in some states — is a separate medical order signed by a physician for patients who are seriously ill. It translates your wishes into actionable medical orders used by EMS and care facilities. It works alongside your advance directive, not instead of it.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need both a living will and a healthcare proxy?
Yes, ideally. A living will documents your treatment wishes but cannot anticipate every situation. A healthcare proxy designates a trusted person to make decisions when you cannot. Together they give you comprehensive protection: specific documented wishes plus a decision-maker for situations not covered.
What happens if I have no advance directive and cannot make decisions?
Physicians will turn to family members following a statutory hierarchy (typically spouse, then adult children, then parents, then siblings). If there is no family or family disagrees, courts may appoint a guardian. Having no advance directive puts all decisions in others' hands without guidance from you.
Can I change my living will or healthcare proxy?
Yes. You can change or revoke either document at any time as long as you have decision-making capacity. Inform your healthcare proxy, your doctor, and any facilities where your records are kept. Destroy old copies to prevent confusion.
Does my advance directive work in other states?
Generally yes — most states honor advance directives from other states, but exact legal requirements vary. If you spend significant time in multiple states, consider state-specific documents for each. Physician Orders (POLST/MOST/POST) are state-specific by definition.
Where should I store my advance directive?
Keep the original in a known, accessible location (not a safety deposit box). Give copies to your healthcare proxy, primary care physician, and any specialists. If you are admitted to a hospital or nursing facility, provide a copy. Some states maintain registries where you can file your directive.
Renidy connects grieving families with compassionate end-of-life professionals. Find support near you.